Rate this post

Bornean fanged frogs were once thought to hide as many as 18 species behind one familiar face. A new genetic study of more than 13,000 genes says the real number is closer to six or seven, and the lines between them are blurry.

Discovery is rarely an adventure scene

When people hear about a new species, they often picture a daring explorer climbing a remote mountain and stumbling on a creature nobody has ever seen. Herpetologist Kin Onn Chan of Michigan State University says that is not how it usually goes. “But most of the time it’s far less glamorous,” he said.

More often, scientists revisit animals they already know. With better tools and fresh data, they find that groups once treated as a single species are more distinct than anyone realized. Chan studies amphibians and reptiles, and he notes that scientists have named more than 9,000 amphibian species, with about 100 to 200 new ones added each year.

A small brown frog with tooth-like projections

One example is a group of small brown frogs in Southeast Asia known as Bornean fanged frogs. The name comes from the tooth-like projections along their jaws. One member of the group, Limnonectes kuhlii, has been known to science since 1838.

Over the past two decades, genetic research suggested that this apparently single species might actually be as many as 18. Animals that look alike but are genetically distinct are called cryptic species, and advances in genetic sequencing have made hidden lineages much easier to find. As Chan put it, “a ton of cryptic species are being discovered left and right.”

What 13,000 genes revealed

To test whether the frogs had been underestimated, Chan and his colleagues collected DNA from specimens across the mountainous rainforests of Malaysian Borneo. The team examined more than 13,000 genes across the frogs’ genomes.

See also  Why mosquitoes bite some people while skipping others entirely

Their results, published in the journal Systematic Biology, showed that the frogs sort into several genetic groups. But the data did not back the idea of 18 species. Instead, about six or seven of those clusters qualify as distinct species. “It’s not just one species. But it’s not 18 species, either,” Chan said.

The researchers also found significant interbreeding among the frogs. “We found a ton of gene flow going on,” Chan said. That exchange of genetic material blurs the boundaries scientists use to define species.

Why the count matters for conservation

Getting the number right is not just an academic debate. A 2023 analysis of roughly 8,000 amphibian species found that two out of five are threatened with extinction, making amphibians the most endangered group of vertebrates. Chan, who contributed to that study, stresses that recognizing species is essential to protecting them. “There are so many species in the world that we still haven’t discovered, and that could go extinct before we can give them a name,” he said.

But splitting too aggressively has a cost. If one species is divided into many smaller ones too quickly, each new species can look like it lives in a very small area, which can make its conservation status seem more severe than it is. “We cannot possibly conserve everything, so we have to triage and decide how to allocate limited resources towards what we think are the highest priorities,” Chan said. “We could be putting names on things that shouldn’t be prioritized.”

Species as a continuum

Chan says the fanged frogs show that a new species rarely appears in a sudden moment. “It’s not like all of a sudden, boom. It’s more of a continuum,” he said. Some of the growing number of proposed cryptic species may reflect how scientists analyze data rather than clear biological divisions.

See also  Old museum frogs point to a killer fungus behind a 50-year mystery

The same pattern is turning up in insects, fish, birds, and mammals, where many species may be hiding in plain sight. Earlier estimates put the number of species on Earth at about 8.7 million. More recent models that account for cryptic species suggest the true total could be far higher, possibly 7 to 250 times that figure.

The study points to a speciation “gray zone” where drawing a firm line is hard.

What this means

For a frog that looks like any other small brown frog on the forest floor, the answer to “how many kinds are there?” depends on how closely you look and where you decide the line goes. The Bornean work suggests the honest answer may be a fuzzy one, and that conservation plans need to account for that.

Source: ScienceDaily