A butterfly seen all over Central and South America has been hiding a secret. For more than two centuries, scientists treated the genus Colobura as a single widespread species. A new study says there are three, and they look almost identical.
A familiar butterfly with a hidden identity
Colobura butterflies are hard to miss in tropical America. Researcher Anisha Sapkota, a doctoral student at the Florida Museum of Natural History, put it simply: “If you go to the neotropics, Colobura is one of the first butterflies you see.”
Their caterpillars eat the leaves of Cecropia trees, which are among the most recognizable trees in the region. Both groups range across a huge area, from parts of the Andes and the Brazilian Amazon to the Atlantic Rainforest and the Caribbean islands.
Cecropia has 61 recognized species, many of them limited to small areas. Colobura looked very different. After Carl Linnaeus described Colobura dirce in 1758, scientists spent more than 200 years treating the whole genus as one species. A second species was formally recognized in 2001. Now Sapkota and her colleagues have described a third, Colobura cryptica, in the journal Zootaxa.
A mystery that goes back to 1852
Adult Colobura are very hard to tell apart. The main clue is a gray stripe on the underside of the front wings, which can be a little wider or narrower, and may or may not reach a yellow band.
The caterpillars are easier. They have velvety black bodies with yellow spines that end in sharp barbs, a warning to predators. Under those spines are small cream-colored markings that look like teardrops or rings, or are missing altogether.
In 1852, Dutch entomologist Jan Sepp suggested that different markings meant different species. Other researchers disagreed, and that view held for about 150 years. In 2001, Keith Willmott and colleagues revisited Sepp’s idea and described a second species, Colobura annulata. “We assumed that was the problem solved,” said Willmott, now a curator at the Florida Museum’s McGuire Center for Lepidoptera and Biodiversity.
Caterpillars with no markings at all
About 25 years later, Willmott’s colleague Andrés Orellana found hungry Colobura caterpillars stripping a young Cecropia tree in Venezuela. They had the usual black bodies and yellow spines, but none of the cream-colored markings seen in the two known species. He photographed them and sent the images to Willmott.
That gave Sapkota a reason to dig deeper. She combined DNA work with a close look at the butterflies themselves. DNA barcodes came from a long-running survey of butterflies and moths in Costa Rica, and older museum specimens from across the tropics were sequenced at the University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center.
An invisible clue in the wings
Looking at preserved butterflies, Sapkota first found few differences. Then she noticed a faint violet shimmer on the underside of some wings, stronger in some specimens than others. That hinted at ultraviolet light, which humans cannot see but many butterflies can.
She tested it. “I checked it with a spectrometer and found that even though the butterflies didn’t look violet to me, it reflected UV light,” she said. All three species reflect ultraviolet light, but at different wavelengths. Together with the caterpillar markings and the DNA, the UV readings told a consistent story. The genetic results showed three distinct evolutionary lineages.
Three species, same forest, no mixing
Colobura dirce has the widest range, from Mexico to southeastern Brazil. Colobura annulata also covers a large area but is absent from the Greater Antilles. The new Colobura cryptica has the smallest known range, from southern Mexico to the foothills of the Andes.
Their ranges overlap, and the three can live in the same places at the same time. Yet the nuclear DNA showed no evidence of hybridization. Sapkota called it “crazy to think about”, since the butterflies look almost exactly the same.
What this means
New species usually appear when populations are separated, for example by a mountain range. That does not seem to explain this case. The researchers suspect the butterflies may use the forest in different ways. Sapkota said Colobura dirce is typically found in the undergrowth, while the other two are usually in the canopy, but she noted that studies have sent mixed signals.
Another open question is how the butterflies find the right mate. Some moths and butterflies use scent, but the new UV differences may offer a visual signal. Similar UV-reflecting wing scales are known or suspected in garden whites, sulfur butterflies and wood tiger moths. Sapkota is testing whether Colobura use the same trick, and so far the results are not clear.
The discovery shows how much can remain unknown even about a common, easy-to-spot animal. Answering the remaining questions will take fieldwork. As Sapkota put it, “Someone has to go the field to find it out themselves.”
Source: ScienceDaily



