Dog owners have long suspected that their pets can read a smile or a frown. A new brain imaging study of pet dogs suggests that happy human faces get special treatment in the canine brain, and that dogs may also tell fear apart from anger and sadness.
Dogs are famous for picking up on how the people around them feel. They seem to notice laughter, tears and scowls. Until now, though, scientists knew very little about what actually goes on inside a dog’s head when it looks at a human face.
A team led by researchers at the University of Vienna set out to change that. Their results, published August 7 in the journal iScience, give a closer look at how a dog’s brain responds to our expressions.
Why dogs are worth studying
People are very good at spotting tiny changes on a face. According to the scientists behind the study, dogs share that talent, which makes them a fascinating animal to study.
“By studying their brains, we can understand what adaptations have developed to support their remarkable social and emotional understanding of humans,” says first author Raúl Hernández-Pérez of the University of Vienna.
What happens when a dog sees a smile
The team started with happiness. Earlier research had hinted that cheerful human expressions might matter a lot to dogs, so it seemed like a good place to begin.
In the first experiment, eight dogs had their brains scanned while they looked at photos of strangers. Some of the people in the pictures were smiling, and others wore a neutral expression.
When the dogs looked at happy faces, two brain areas became more active: the temporal cortex and the caudate nucleus. The temporal cortex is linked to more advanced thinking and processing. The caudate nucleus is part of the brain’s reward system, the network that responds to things that feel good or worthwhile.
Laura Cuaya, the study’s senior author, also from the University of Vienna, was especially struck by that second region. She began the work at the National Autonomous University of Mexico and later expanded it with colleagues at Eötvös Loránd University in Hungary.
“It suggests that happy human faces may have emotional significance for dogs,” she says.
Telling fear apart from anger and sadness
Next, the researchers wanted to know whether the dog brain reacts to other emotions in its own way. In a second experiment, 12 dogs viewed pictures of people looking happy, angry, scared or sad.
To make sense of the results, the team used machine learning, a type of computer analysis that is good at finding patterns in large amounts of data. It compared the brain activity recorded for each kind of face.
Smiles once again stood out. The activity in the temporal cortex and caudate nucleus was distinctive enough that the researchers could fairly easily separate the dogs’ responses to happy faces from their responses to the three negative ones.
The bigger surprise came when the team looked at the whole brain. Fear produced a different pattern of activity than anger and sadness did. In other words, the dogs were not just sorting faces into “good” and “bad.” According to the researchers, this is the first evidence that dogs can tell specific negative human expressions apart.
What this means, and what it does not
The scientists are careful not to overstate their findings. Seeing a difference in brain activity does not necessarily mean that dogs feel emotions the same way humans do.
A photo is also a very limited way to communicate. In daily life, dogs read people using many clues at once: the face, the body, the tone of voice and even scent. A still picture captures only a small slice of that.
There is another limit worth knowing. Every dog in the study was a pet living with a family. The researchers point out that free-ranging dogs, such as those that live on the street, grow up in a very different social world and may read human signals in a different way.
A different road to the same skill
Cuaya finds the dog story especially interesting because of how it compares with our closest relatives. When scientists compare humans with other primates, shared abilities may trace back to a common ancestor.
“With dogs, the story is totally different. They followed a very different evolutionary path, yet through domestication, they developed the social abilities needed to understand and cooperate with us,” she says.
Next, the team plans to take a more dog-centered approach. They want to explore how dogs combine different brain signals to understand the people around them, and to compare how dogs and humans process the same emotional information.
Why it matters for dog owners
For anyone who shares a home with a dog, the takeaway is simple: your pet may be paying closer attention to your face than you think. Cuaya hopes the work helps people see their dogs in a new light.
“I would like people to see dogs as emotional beings,” she says. “They have evolved with us to understand our expressions and cooperate with us, and recognizing that can change how we communicate with and care for them.”
Source: ScienceDaily



